Balanced Memory Configurations with 4th Generation AMD EPYC Processors

The memory subsystem is a key component of AMD EPYC server architecture which can greatly affect the overall server performance.  When properly configured, the memory subsystem can deliver maximum memory bandwidth and low memory latency.  When the memory subsystem is incorrectly configured, memory bandwidth available to the server can be impacted and overall server performance can be reduced.

This paper explains the concept of balanced memory configurations that yields the highest possible memory bandwidth performance from the AMD EPYC architecture.  By increasing the number of populated DIMMs from minimum to maximum, examples of balanced and unbalanced memory configurations are shown to illustrate their effect on memory subsystem performance.

This paper specifically covers the 4th Gen AMD EPYC processor family (EPYC 9004), formerly code named "Genoa". For other processor families, see the Balanced Memory papers section.

Access to the data stored on memory DIMMs is controlled by memory controllers within the processor. The 4th Gen AMD EPYC family processors have twelve Unified Memory Controllers (UMC). Each UMC has one memory channel, and each memory channel supports up to two memory DIMM slots. Note that the previous generations of AMD EPYC processors support eight memory channels per processor socket. This represents a 50% increase in number of supported memory channels per processor with this latest EPYC generation.

Lenovo ThinkSystem servers with 4th Gen AMD EPYC processors will support twelve memory channels per socket and one DIMM per channel (1DPC) only. Figure 1 illustrates the logical view of the 4th Gen AMD EPYC processor. Each processor supports twelve UMCs and twelve DDR channels. Each DDR channel support one DIMM slot (1DPC).

Figure 1. 4th Gen AMD EPYC Processor – logical view

Figure 2 illustrates the layout of the physical DIMM slots on Lenovo servers that support 4th Gen AMD EPYC Processor. As shown, on one side of the processor socket, DIMM slot connected to channel G is the closest DIMM slot to the processor socket, followed by channel H, I, J, K. Channel L is the farthest DIMM slot from the processor socket. On the other side of the processor socket, DIMM slot connected to channel A is the closest to the processor socket, and DIMM slot connected to channel F is the farthest from the processor socket.

Figure 2. 4th Gen AMD EPYC Processor – physical DIMM layout view

We will use both views of the processor to help illustrate the DIMM population and memory interleaving for all memory configurations.

To illustrate various memory topologies for a processor, different memory configurations will be designated as L:K:J:I:H:G:A:B:C:D:E:F where each letter indicates the number of memory DIMMs populated on each memory channel.

• A refers to Memory Channel 3 on UMC3
• B refers to Memory Channel 4 on UMC4
• C refers to Memory Channel 0 on UMC0
• D refers to Memory Channel 5 on UMC5
• E refers to Memory Channel 1 on UMC1
• F refers to Memory Channel 2 on UMC2
• G refers to Memory Channel 9 on UMC9
• H refers to Memory Channel 10 on UMC10
• I refers to Memory Channel 6 on UMC6
• J refers to Memory Channel 11 on UMC11
• K refers to Memory Channel 7 on UMC7
• L refers to Memory Channel 8 on UMC8

The order of the DIMM sequence in the notation also maps to the actual physical order sequence of the DIMM slots as shown in figure 2 above.

As an example, a 1:0:1:0:1:0:1:0:1:0:1:0 memory configuration has 1 DIMM populated on Memory Channels L, J, H, A, C, and E. Channels K, I, G, B, D, and F are left unpopulated.

The 4th Gen AMD EPYC processor family optimizes memory accesses by creating interleave sets across the memory controllers and memory channels. For example, if two memory channels were populated with the same total memory capacity and the same number of ranks, a 2-channel interleave set is created across the two memory channels.

Interleaving enables higher memory bandwidth by spreading contiguous memory accesses across all memory channels in a memory interleave set rather than sending all memory accesses to one memory channel. This allows the processors to access multiple memory channels simultaneously. In order to form an interleave set, all channels are required to have the same DIMM type, the same total memory capacity and ranks.

For EPYC 9004 processors, the number of memory channels in an interleave set has to be 2, 4, 6, 8, 10, or 12.

If one interleave set cannot be formed for a particular memory configuration, it is possible to have multiple interleave sets. When this happens, memory bandwidth performance is dependent on the specific memory region being accessed and how many DIMMs comprise the interleave set. For this reason, memory bandwidth performance on memory configurations with multiple interleave sets can be inconsistent. Contiguous memory accesses to a memory region with fewer channels in the interleave set will have lower performance compared to accesses to a memory region with more channels in the interleave set.

Figure 3 illustrates a 2-channel interleave set which results from populating identical memory DIMMs on channel A and channel G. This 2-channel interleave set interleaves data line across memory controllers and between memory channels. Consecutive addresses alternate between the two memory controllers.

Figure 3. 2-channel interleave set across 2 memory controllers and between 2 memory channels

Balanced memory configurations enable optimal memory interleaving which maximizes memory bandwidth performance. The basic guidelines for a balanced memory subsystem are as follows:

1. The number of populated memory channels per socket should be 1, 2, 4, 6, 8, 10, or 12.
2. All populated memory channel should have the same memory configuration. Since only 1DPC is supported on Lenovo servers with support for 4th Gen AMD EPYC Processors, it means all populated memory channels should have identical DIMMs.
3. All processor sockets on the same physical server should have the same DIMM configuration.
4. All NUMA domains in the same processor socket need to have identical memory configuration. This applies when the processor is set to NPS2 or NPS4 (NPS = Numa node per socket).

We will refer to the above guidelines as balanced memory guidelines 1, 2, 3, and 4 throughout this paper.

STREAM Triad is a simple, synthetic benchmark designed to measure sustainable memory bandwidth throughput. The goal is to measure the highest memory bandwidth supported by the system. STREAM Triad will be used to measure the sustained memory bandwidth of various memory configurations discussed in this paper. Unless otherwise stated, all test configurations were done using 64GB 2R RDIMMs running at 4800MHz.

As described in the Memory Interleaving section, it is possible to get inconsistent memory bandwidth performance when there are multiple interleave sets in a memory configuration. To account for this behavior, we configure each test run to make sure the STREAM benchmark accesses the entire memory address map. The reported test result reflects the average memory bandwidth performance for these configurations. In reality, memory bandwidth performance in configurations with multiple interleave sets can be unpredictable, depending on which interleave set is being accessed. For this reason, we also provide memory bandwidth measurement for the worst case. This happens when memory in the interleave set with the lowest number of memory channels is being accessed.

With 4th Gen AMD EPYC Processors, the following memory configurations are supported on Lenovo servers.

In our lab study, we used a 2-socket server, but the findings should be applicable to both 1-socket and 2-socket servers. We will limit this study to cover just the supported memory configurations listed in Table 1 above. We will start with the assumption that balanced memory guideline 3 (described in the Balanced memory configurations section) is followed, i.e. all processor sockets on the same physical server have the same configurations of memory DIMMs. Therefore, we only describe memory configuration for one processor. The other processor will have identical memory configuration.

In the first part of our study, all the DIMMs were 64GB dual-rank RDIMMs (met balanced memory guideline 2), and we populated 1, 2, 4, 6, 8, 10, and 12 DIMMs per socket (met balanced memory guideline 3). Processor is set to NPS1 so guideline 4 does not apply. This means all memory configurations covered in this part of the paper are balanced memory configurations.

For more information on supported DIMM types and DIMM configurations, please refer to the Lenovo Press product guides:

• 1U and 2U rack servers:
  • ThinkSystem SR635 V3: https://lenovopress.lenovo.com/lp1609
  • ThinkSystem SR655 V3: https://lenovopress.lenovo.com/lp1610
  • ThinkSystem SR645 V3: https://lenovopress.lenovo.com/lp1607
  • ThinkSystem SR665 V3: https://lenovopress.lenovo.com/lp1608
• HPC servers
  • ThinkSystem SR675 V3: https://lenovopress.lenovo.com/lp1611
  • ThinkSystem SD665 V3: https://lenovopress.lenovo.com/lp1612
  • ThinkSystem SD665-N V3: https://lenovopress.lenovo.com/lp1613

We start with only one memory DIMM populated in 0:0:0:0:0:0:1:0:0:0:0:0 configuration as shown in Figure 4 below.

Figure 4. 0:0:0:0:0:0:1:0:0:0:0:0 memory configuration relative memory bandwidth: 9%

Only one memory channel was populated with memory DIMM in this configuration. Utilizing only one of the twelves memory channels available limits the memory bandwidth support of this configuration to 9% of the full potential memory bandwidth this processor can support.

The best way to increase memory bandwidth from this configuration is by using more lower density DIMMs. Two 32GB RDIMMs populated on two memory channels, or four 16GB RDIMMs on four memory channels would provide the same memory capacity while greatly improve memory bandwidth support by a factor or two or four respectively.

The recommended and supported memory configuration with four memory DIMMs is the 0:0:0:0:0:1:1:0:0:0:0:0 memory configuration as shown in Figure 5.

Figure 5. 0:0:0:0:0:1:1:0:0:0:0:0 memory configuration relative memory bandwidth: 18%

One 2-channel interleave set is formed across the two memory channels in this memory configuration. Only two memory channels are populated with memory which reduces memory bandwidth of this memory configuration to about one sixth of the full potential memory bandwidth. It was measured at 18% of the maximum achievable memory bandwidth supported by the processor.

The best way to increase memory bandwidth in this configuration is to utilize lower density DIMMs to increase the number of populated memory channels while maintaining the same capacity.

The recommended and supported memory configuration with four memory DIMMs is the 0:0:0:1:0:1:1:0:1:0:0:0 memory configuration as shown in Figure 6.

Figure 6. 0:0:0:1:0:1:1:0:1:0:0:0 memory configuration relative memory bandwidth: 35%

One 4-channel interleave set is formed across 4 memory channels in this configuration. Memory bandwidth was measured at 35% of the maximum achievable memory bandwidth supported by the processor.

The recommended and supported memory configuration with six memory DIMMs is the 0:0:0:1:1:1:1:1:1:0:0:0 memory configuration as shown in Figure 7.

Figure 7. 0:0:0:1:1:1:1:1:1:0:0:0 memory configuration relative memory bandwidth: 51%

One 6-channel interleave set is formed across 6 memory channels in this configuration. Memory bandwidth was measured at 51% of the maximum achievable memory bandwidth supported by the processor.

The recommended and supported memory configuration with eight memory DIMMs is the 0:1:0:1:1:1:1:1:1:0:1:0 memory configuration as shown in Figure 8.

Figure 8. 0:1:0:1:1:1:1:1:1:0:1:0 memory configuration relative memory bandwidth: 68%

One 8-channel interleave set is formed across 8 memory channels in this configuration. Memory bandwidth was measured at 68% of the maximum achievable memory bandwidth supported by the processor.

The recommended and supported memory configuration with ten memory DIMMs is the 0:1:1:1:1:1:1:1:1:1:1:0 memory configuration as shown in Figure 9.

Figure 9. 0:1:1:1:1:1:1:1:1:1:1:0 memory configuration relative memory bandwidth: 84%

One 10-channel interleave set is formed across 10 memory channels in this configuration. Memory bandwidth was measured at 84% of the maximum achievable memory bandwidth supported by the processor

This is a fully populated configuration 1:1:1:1:1:1:1:1:1:1:1:1 as shown in Figure 10.

Figure 10. 1:1:1:1:1:1:1:1:1:1:1:1 memory configuration relative memory bandwidth: 100%

One 12-channel interleave set is formed across all 12 memory channels in this configuration. Memory bandwidth reached the maximum achievable memory bandwidth supported by the processor

The following table shows the summary of the relative memory bandwidths of all supported memory configurations that were evaluated. As mentioned before, these memory configurations are balanced configurations with NPS1 setting (NPS = NUMA node per socket). One memory interleave set is formed and memory bandwidth performance is consistent in all configurations.

All examples above were with NPS1 setting (NPS1 = 1 NUMA node per socket). This mean there is only one node or one memory partition in each processor socket. With NPS1, all memory configurations discussed above are balanced memory configurations. However, that might not be the case when the system is set to NPS2 or NPS4. When the system is set to NPS2 or NPS4, we need to take guideline 4 into consideration. As listed above, guideline 4 states that all NUMA domains in the same processor socket need to have identical memory configuration.

Let’s take a few examples to explain this further.

Example 1 – Configuration with 12 DIMMs

Logical view of this memory configuration is as shown in Figure 11.

Figure 11. Configuration with 12 DIMMs – balanced memory configuration with NPS1/NPS2/NPS4

The dotted red lines show the partitions within the processor socket when it is set to NPS2 and NPS4. In this memory configuration, DIMM configurations are identical in each node for both NPS2 and NPS4 settings. This memory configuration is a balanced memory configuration for NPS1, NPS2, and NPS4.

Example 2 – Configuration with 10 DIMMs

Logical view of this memory configuration is as shown in Figure 12.

Figure 12. Configuration with 10 DIMMs – balanced memory configuration with NPS1 and NPS2, but not with NPS4

In this memory configuration, DIMM configurations are identical in each node for NPS2, but not NPS4. With NPS4, two nodes have 3 DIMMs populated, and two other nodes have only 2 DIMMs populated. Taking guideline 4 into account, this memory configuration is balanced with NPS1 and NPS2, but it is not a balanced memory configuration with NPS4. With NPS4, the cores in the nodes with the 3-channel interleave set will have direct local access to higher memory bandwidth compared to the cores in the nodes with 2-channel interleave set.

Balanced Memory Configuration Summary

Table 3 shows the summary of whether a memory configuration is balanced with different NPS settings.

To maximize memory bandwidth of a server, the following rules should be followed:

1. Balanced the memory across the processor sockets – all processor sockets on the same physical server should have the same memory DIMM configuration.
2. Balance the memory across the memory controllers – all memory controllers on a processor socket should have the same memory DIMM configuration.
3. Balance the memory across the populated memory channels – all populated memory channels should have the same total memory capacity and the same total number of ranks.

All Lenovo server offerings with 4th Gen AMD EPYC Processors support one DIMM slot per DDR channel (1DPC). Peak memory bandwidth performance is achieved when each processor socket is populated with 12 identical DIMMs.

For optimal memory bandwidth configuration, follow these steps:

1. Determine the required memory capacity per socket.
2. Divide this memory capacity by twelve to determine the minimum memory capacity needed per DDR channel.
3. Round this calculated memory capacity per channel to the nearest DIMM capacity.
4. Populated each processor socket with twelve identical DIMMs with the capacity determined in the step above.

Example:

A 1TB total memory capacity is required for SR665 V3, which supports two processors. Follow the steps highlighted above:

1. Memory capacity required per socket = 1TB / 2-sockets = 512GB.
2. Memory capacity required per DDR channel = 512GB / 12 DDR channels = 42.67GB.
3. Round up to the next available DIMM capacity = 64GB DIMM.
4. Populated this server with 24x 64GB DIMMs.

Our balanced memory configuration guideline 2 states that all populated memory channel should have the same memory configuration. This often means using the same DIMM to populate all memory channels. However, there are cases where, despite our recommendations, the customer had a memory capacity requirement that cannot be met with a balanced memory configuration.

One of such examples is a mixed capacity DIMM memory configuration, i.e. DDR channels are populated with different DIMM capacities. In this case, it is an unbalanced memory configuration with multiple memory interleave sets. This results in non-optimal memory performance. We will provide an example and walk through one such configuration to help illustrate the performance impact.

Example: A customer has a memory capacity requirement of 576GB per socket.

If we follow our recommendations above for a balanced memory configuration, the memory configuration that meets this capacity requirement is the one shown in figure 13 below. Each processor socket is populated with twelve 64GB DIMMs, for a total of 64GB x 12 = 768GB per socket. This configuration has more memory capacity than required. It is a balanced memory configuration. It has one interleave set and achieves maximum supported memory bandwidth.

Figure 13. Balanced memory configuration, total capacity = 768GB vs requirement = 576GB, relative bandwidth: 100%

If the customer insists on having a memory configuration with the exact memory capacity required, one might go with a memory configuration as shown in Figure 14 below. This configuration does not follow our guideline 2 and it is an unbalanced configuration. Two memory interleave sets are formed as shown in Figure 14.

Memory bandwidth performance in this configuration is not consistent and is dependent on which interleave set is being accessed. The average memory bandwidth performance for this configuration is 73% of the maximum possible bandwidth supported, but it could get as low as 51% of the maximum bandwidth when the smaller interleave set with 6-channel (the yellow interleave set) is being accessed.

Figure 14. Unbalanced memory configuration, total capacity = 576GB vs requirement = 576GB, relative average bandwidth: 73%, min memory bandwidth: 51%

Overall server performance is affected by the memory subsystem which can provide both high memory bandwidth and low memory access latency when properly configured. Balancing memory across the memory controllers and the memory channels produces memory configurations which can efficiently interleave memory references among its DIMMs, producing the highest possible memory bandwidth. An unbalanced memory configuration can reduce the total memory bandwidth to as low as 9% of a balanced memory configuration with 12 identical DIMMs installed per processor.

Implementing all three (or four for NPS2 and NPS4) of the balanced memory guidelines described in this paper results in balanced memory configurations producing the best possible memory bandwidth and overall performance.

All supported memory configurations on Lenovo ThinkSystem servers that support 4th Gen AMD EPYC Processors are balanced memory configurations (with NPS1). Peak memory performance is achieved with 12 DIMMs populated per processor.

This paper was produced by the following team of performance specialists:

Ngan (Nathan) Pham is a Principal Engineer and System Performance Architect in the Lenovo Infrastructure Solutions Group Performance Laboratory in Morrisville, NC. He has spent 21 years between IBM and Lenovo working on system performance. His focus has been in system performance architecture, modeling, analysis, workload profiling, tuning and optimization. In his current role, he is responsible for all aspects of Lenovo ISG system architecture and performance. Nathan holds a Bachelor of Science degree in Computer Engineering and a Master of Science degree in Computer Engineering, both from North Carolina State University.

Peter Xu is a Systems Performance Verification Engineer in the Lenovo Infrastructure Solutions Group Performance Laboratory in Morrisville, NC, USA. His current role includes CPU, Memory, and PCIe subsystem analysis and performance validation against functional specifications and vendor targets. Peter holds a Bachelor of Electronic and Information Engineering and a Master of Electronic Science and Technology, both from Hangzhou Dianzi University.

This paper is based in part on the Lenovo Press paper, Balanced Memory Configurations with 2nd and 3rd Generation AMD EPYC Processors. Thanks to the authors:

• Nathan Pham
• Joseph Jakubowski
• Jamal Ayoubi

This paper is one of a series of papers on Balanced Memory configurations:

• Balanced Memory Configurations for 2-Socket Servers with 4th and 5th Gen Intel Xeon Scalable Processors
• Balanced Memory Configurations with 4th Generation AMD EPYC Processors
• Balanced Memory Configurations for 2-Socket Servers with 3rd Gen Intel Xeon Scalable Processors
• Balanced Memory Configurations with 2nd Gen and 3rd Gen AMD EPYC Processors
• Balanced Memory Configurations with 2nd Gen Intel Xeon Scalable Processors
• Balanced Memory Configurations with 1st Generation Intel Xeon Scalable Processors
• Maximizing System x and ThinkServer Performance with a Balanced Memory Configuration